You don’t have to sob in your matzoh anymore about being without Miracle Whip. Simply play with your mayo for a spread you’ll slather on everything.
Granted, this isn’t exactly like Miracle Whip (the real product contains proprietary ingredients), but in a pinch, this is a wonderful sub. Miracle Whip’s main additions are mustard and sweeteners. We’ll accomplish the acidity instead with vinegar, and your favorite sweetener in place of the corn syrup used to sweeten the spread.
Tip: Make sure to process your sugar slightly into a powder. When granular sweeteners are added to cold ingredients, they sometimes retain their granular state and deliver crunch when you want creamy.
1 cup mayonnaise
1 tsp vinegar
1 tablespoon sugar equivalent replacement
Mix. Let flavors work together. Keep refrigerated. Use within the week.